We can safely say that my strength as a blogger doesn’t lie with my knowledge of the technology. Hell, I’m still trying to get the damned MyBlogLog pictures to appear in the sidebar.
That’s why posts like: How to Get More Comments, Less Spam from Michel Fortin’s blog are candy to me; they help me build a more successful blog without toiling any harder at the keyboard (the toiling part’s been happening a lot lately).
(Knowledge like this also plays nicely into my vision of the copywriter as marketer; the more you know about marketing technology, the more value you bring to the table.)
Nofollow Settings
Mike’s current post covers “nofollow” settings – a topic that resurfaces frequently. From Fortin:
With the WordPress default package, links within comments apply a “no-follow” attribution, which was initially meant to curb spam. (Many spammers have exploited this in the past, for the sole purpose of gaining linkback popularity and pagerank when search engines index blogs.)
As we now know, this is not true. At least, not any longer.
Spam is almost always automated (spammers use software that “blasts” blog comments all over the ‘Net). And they don’t care. If spammers can get blog viewers and authors to visit their sites, gaining extra backlinks is but a mere bonus for their despicable efforts.
The problem is, just like email anti-spam filtering can kill innocent bystanders (such as legitimate, double opt-in marketers), no-follow penalizes my blog’s commentators in the process.
Essentially, “nofollow” means those who post comments on a blog don’t receive “credit” for a link back to their own blog from the search engines.
Turning off “nofollow” provides an incentive for commentary, though it might also provide an incentive for a lot of meaningless, one-line commentary.
Still, I’ve turned off “nofollow” using this neat plugin:
But rather than being forced to tweak the code, my friend Denis de Bernardy, author of the Semiologic Package of plugins, which I highly recommend, offers a Do Follow plugin that reverses the default no-follow attribution.
This morning I noticed a similar WordPress plug-in which turns off “nofollow” for anyone posting ten comments. Amusingly called Link Love, you can download it at the AllPassionMarketing site.
Philosophically speaking, I want to reward those who take the time to comment, yet I’d love to do so without rewarding spammers and those who add nothing to the conversation.
























I had the desire to post some short, meaningless comment like “Good one!” But I changed my mind.
I’ll check out that plugin you mentioned. My only thinking is, this may offer an opposite effect — that is, people just making short, meaningless comments in order to reach exceed the minimum to get link love.
If imposing a minimum, I would put it at 3, not 10. And like I mentioned on my blog in response to your comment, Tom, I would use a plugin that forces a minimum word count.
Like James Brausch, my only contention is not the spammers — that’s dealt with Akismet and the comment timeout plugins. It’s more the low quality comments.
Not the short, spammy ones. The ones that are negative, destructive, malicious or meaningless (not the spam kind but genuine comments, even if long, that do not contribute to the conversation).
I do not like trackbacks and have disabled them on my blog for one reason. Spammers abuse the heck out of them. By simply adding a math plugin that asks readers to do a simple math calculation I have reduced my spam to a big old zero folks!
Mike
Mike, you can use Akismet. Trackbacks are very useful, particularly from an SEO standpoint. Akismet or Spam Karma kills all of the trackback spam. The math captcha (or question captcha) is a good idea. I never use captcha that are graphic-based, because they are a pain and hard to see sometimes.
Michel; That plug-in I mentioned can apparently configure to as few (or many) posts as you’d like. I might test it (in my spare time) this weekend.
Michael; Aksimet & the Bad Behavior plug-ins work well for me, and I’d like to avoid the graphic captcha because they irritate the hell out of me.
The math version makes much more sense.
I don’t know, it seems to be a “better” problem to have than no comments;-)
It would seem to be a fine line to encourage a conversation, but discourage the other guy from commenting. (“your comments are not good enough – no soup for you”-)
Just trying to add a balancing opinion and some levity…
Steve, I’d respond to your comment, but it simply doesn’t make the grade…
Seriously, thanks for stopping by. The more I think about it, the good likely outweighs the bad.
In any case, I’m giving it a try.
Michel – I tried to enable Akismet many times on my blog and could never get my activation code to work. I am very technical and just could not get it to work.
Tom, you should add the ability to get emails in response to posts. That will pull more folks back to you blog.
Mike
Michael: Just added the Return to Comments plugin (upgraded to WP 2.1). Looks like it’s actually working.
Great!
Michael, you need a WordPress.com account (don’t need to use it, just need the account number, aka API key, to activate the plugin). I registered once and use it on all my WP blogs.
Hi Michel – Tried that (twice), but the API key never worked. FYI Michel, just added you to my blogroll. – Mike
I agree with disabling the noFollow attribute, and have done so on my blog.